Thursday, April 29, 2010

Who's The Victim?

Ultimately, a Supreme Court Judge decides that the only person to face punishment for Dianne Brimble's death is Dianne Brimble herself and the real victim was the man who gave her an illegal drug:

Supreme Court Justice Roderick Howie... described the supply as a "social" or consensual one... (and) "must be on the absolute lowest range of such offences".

Justice Howie... said Ms Brimble's death had impacted greatly upon Mr Wilhelm, with evidence tendered revealing he had "an acute mental illness" as a result of depression and anxiety... "No punishment I can give will be anything like the punishment he has suffered over the years," Justice Howie said. He said he hoped Mr Wilhelm could now get on with his life.
If Mrs Brimble had been loaned an unlicensed air gun and accidentally killed or maimed herself with it, the gun's owner would be punished for the supply of an illegal weapon, despite an air gun being on the lowest range of such weapons.

What's so different about supplying illegal drugs? Are they not a loaded weapon?

And why has it been impossible to get some sort of justice in the Brimble case?

-- Nick

2 comments:

kae said...

I heard last night on late news update before the late news that they're talking about reopening the coroners' inquiry... they had to shut it down while the charges on Wilhelm were prosecuted.

I think the circumstances of Dianne Brimble's death and the disregard and disrespect of the group of men who shared that room showed for women in general, and that they were in the room when she was incapacited and did not call for assistance shows a callous disregard....

I hope that it goes to court.

kae said...

It appears that the judge seems to have forgotten about Dianne Brimble as the victim, she's dead. But what about her children and family who loved her? What about their suffering?